Fighting Chance Consensus Rankings - Shortstop

I will once again continue on making the intro make absolutely zero sense and have no relevance to the article Today, I am going to recite the lyrics to my favorite song. Here we go!

"When you're sliding into first and your pants begin to burst, that's diarrhea, diarrhea. When you're sliding into two and your pants are filled with goo, that's diarrhea, diarrhea. When you're sliding into third and you feel a greasy turd, that's diarrhea, diarrhea. When you're sliding into home and your pants are filled with foam, that's diarrhea, diarrhea." You're welcome.

Anyways, here are the Fighting Chance Fantasy Consensus Rankings for the Shortstop position. Here's who contributed to the rankings and where you can find them on Twitter. There are some notes on the position after the consensus rankings and each participants rankings are listed at the bottom for reference.

Ryan Hallam - @fightingchance
Steve Rapin - @fantasygeek37
Patrick Wisnewski - @polkapat
Kari Thomas - @FCFKariThomas
Kevin Tomkins - @ktompkinsii

Consensus Average
1 Trea Turner, WAS 1.8
2 Alex Bregman, HOU 2
3 Manny Machado, SD 3
4 Francisco Lindor, CLE 3.6
5 Trevor Story, COL 5
6 Javier Baez, CHC 5.4
7 Carlos Correa, HOU 6.2
8 Xander Bogaerts, BOS 8.4
T-9 Adaberto Mondesi, KC 9.2
T-9 Jean Segura, PHI 9.2
11 Corey Seager, LAD 11
12 Gleyber Torres, NYY 11.4
13 Jose Peraza, CIN 12.8
14 Tim Anderson, CWS 13.8
15 Jurickson Profar, OAK 14.8
16 Paul DeJong, STL 15.6
17 Amed Rosario, NYM 19.6
T-18 Jorge Polanco, MIN 20.2
T-18 Willy Adames, TB 20.2
20 Andrelton Simmons, LAA 21.6
21 Ketel Marte, ARI 22
22 Elvis Andrus, TEX 23
23 Eduardo Escobar, ARI 23.2
24 Marcus Semien, OAK 24
25 Fernando Tatis Jr, SD 27
26 Didi Gregorius, NYY 28.2
27 Marwin Gonzalez, MIN 28.6
28 Johan Camargo, ATL 28.8
29 Dansby Swanson, ATL 29.6
30 Troy Tulowitzki, NYY 29.8

Notes

  • Eight out of ten shortstop were consensus top ten among our experts, which is the highest number to date. Adalberto Mondesi and Jean Segura were the only two in the top ten that weren't consensus picks.
  • Amed Rosario is one of the most divisive among our rankings. He ranked anywhere from 15 on Kari's board down to 28 on Kevin's.
  • If you want someone to sell you on Didi Gregorius, you may want to talk to Kevin. He had him ranked 21 while three experts didn't even have him in their top 30.
  • It looks like the Fighting Chance Crew is much higher on Willy Adames as they have him tied for 18th in their rankings, while he is going as the 28th shortstop off the board in the NFBC over the last few weeks.
Hallam Rapin Thomas Polka Tompkins
1 Trea Turner, WAS 1 Trea Turner, WAS 1 Trea Turner, WAS 1 Alex Bregman, HOU 1 Alex Bregman, HOU
2 Francisco Lindor, CLE 2 Alex Bregman, HOU 2 Alex Bregman, HOU 2 Trea Turner, WAS 2 Francisco Lindor, CLE
3 Alex Bregman, HOU 3 Francisco Lindor, CLE 3 Manny Machado, SD 3 Manny Machado, SD 3 Manny Machado, SD
4 Manny Machado, SD 4 Trevor Story, COL 4 Carlos Correa, HOU 4 Francisco Lindor, CLE 4 Trea Turner, WAS
5 Carlos Correa, HOU 5 Manny Machado, SD 5 Trevor Story, COL 5 Trevor Story, COL 5 Trevor Story, COL
6 Trevor Story, COL 6 Javier Baez, CHC 6 Adalberto Mondesi, KC 6 Javier Baez, CHC 6 Carlos Correa, HOU
7 Adalberto Mondesi, KC 7 Xander Bogaerts, BOS 7 Jean Segura, PHI 7 Carlos Correa, HOU 7 Javier Baez, CHC
8 Javier Baez, CHC 8 Adalberto Mondesi, KC 8 Francisco Lindor, CLE 8 Jean Segura, PHI 8 Xander Bogaerts, BOS
9 Xander Bogaerts, BOS 9 Carlos Correa, HOU 9 Xander Bogaerts, BOS 9 Xander Bogaerts, BOS 9 Corey Seagar, LAD
10 Jean Segura, PHI 10 Jean Segura, PHI 10 Corey Seager, LAD 10 Jose Peraza, CIN 10 Gleyber Torres, NYY
11 Corey Seager, LAD 11 Corey Seager, LAD 11 Gleyber Torres, NYY 11 Tim Anderson, CWS 11 Jean Segura, PHI
12 Gleyber Torres, NYY 12 Gleyber Torres, NYY 12 Jose Peraza, CIN 12 Gleyber Torres, NYY 12 Adalberto Mondesi, KC
13 Jurickson Profar, OAK 13 Jose Peraza, CIN 13 Tim Anderson, CWS 13 Adalberto Mondessi, KC 13 Jose Peraza, CIN
14 Paul DeJong, STL 14 Jurickson Profar, OAK 14 Jurickson Profar, OAK 14 Corey Seager, LAD 14 Jurickson Profar, OAK
15 Tim Anderson, CWS 15 Tim Anderson, CWS 15 Amed Rosario, NYM 15 Paul DeJong, STL 15 Tim Anderson, CWS
16 Jose Peraza, CIN 16 Garrett Hampson, COL 16 Paul DeJong, STL 16 Amed Rosario, NYM 16 Paul DeJong, STL
17 Jorge Polanco, MIN 17 Paul DeJong, STL 17 Andrelton Simmons, LAA 17 Jonathan Villar, BAL 17 Andrelton Simmons, LAA
18 Amed Rosario, NYM 18 Jorge Polanco, MIN 18 Ketel Marte, ARI 18 Andrelton Simmons, LAA 18 Jonathan Villar, BAL
19 Willy Adames, TB 19 Ketel Marte, ARI 19 Jorge Polanco, MIN 19 Willy Adames, TB 19 Willy Adames, TB
20 Eduardo Escobar, ARI 20 Eduardo Escobar, ARI 20 Willy Adames, TB 20 Jurickson Profar, OAK 20 Eduardo Escobar, ARI
21 Ketel Marte, ARI 21 Amed Rosario, NYM 21 Didi Gregorius, NYY 21 Johan Camargo, ATL 21 Ketel Marte, ARI
22 Elvis Andrus, TEX 22 Elvis Andrus,TEX 22 Fernando Tatis Jr, SD 22 Elvis Andrus, TEX 22 Marcus Semien, OAK
23 Marcus Semien, OAK 23 Asdrubal Cabrera, TEX 23 Marcus Semien, OAK 23 Jorge Polanco, MIN 23 Elvis Andrus, TEX
24 Orlando Arcia, MIL 24 Willy Adames, TB 24 Niko Goodrum, DET 24 Marcus Semien, OAK 24 Jorge Polanco, MIN
25 JP Crawford, SEA 25 Chris Taylor, LAD 25 Eduardo Escobar, ARI 25 Jonathan Schoop, MIN 25 Marwin Gonzalez, MIN
26 Freddy Galvis, TOR 26 Andrelton Simmons, LAA 26 Elvis Andrus, TEX 26 Chris Taylor, LAD 26 Fernando Tatis Jr., SD
27 Fernando Tatis Jr, SD 27 Marwin Gonzalez, MIN 27 Brandon Crawford, SF 27 Eduardo Nunez, BOS 27 Didi Gregorius, NYY
28 Troy Tulowitzki, NYY 28 Marcus Semien, OAK 28 Troy Tulowitzki, NYY 28 Dansby Swanson, ATL 28 Amed Rosario, NYM
29 Richie Martin, BAL 29 Fernando Tatis Jr., SD 29 Dansby Swanson, ATL 29 Marwin Gonzalez, MIN 29 Dansby Swanson, ATL
30 Andrelton Simmons, LAA 30 Scott Kingery, PHI 30 Johan Camargo, ATL 30 Yario Munoz, STL 30 Niko Goodrum, DET

Have Your Say